A critique of fredrick jackson turners thesis about the ideals of the american west

Without one another, Cronon argues that neither could have existed. Why or why not? Professor Frederick Turner, to whom I dedicated the book. My Observations In my own observations of the study of history and western frontier history is that academic people who I think are competitive and make a reputation coming up with theories to combat former theories write history.

For example, earlier in this same essay, Turner had described the "evil'' he had in mind in the passage quoted by Davidson and Lytle: In this connection may be noted also the influence of frontier conditions in permitting lax business honor, inflated paper currency and wild-cat banking Allen, for example, has pointed out, that the role of land speculators on the frontier received too little attention in Turner's frontier essays, 47 surely they were among the evils of frontier individualism that he had in mind in his references to the "strenuous competition for the spoils of the new country," the "laxity in government affairs" and in "financial integrity," and "the natural resources open to the shrewdest and the boldest," and in his observation that Besides the ideals of conquest and of discovery, the pioneer had the ideal of personal development, free from social and governmental constraint.

During the frontier era Turner seems to believe that every generation of Americans went back to primitive conditions and repeating the stages of development from primitive to industrial.

Not only has criticism of the thesis ''become a minor industry," as British historian Howard Temperley recently pointed out, 2 but even more so has its defense, at least if neo-Turnerians those Richard Hofstadter aptly described as "friendly revisionists" are included with Turner's disciples.

His critics have denied everything from his basic assumptions to the small details of his argument. That coarseness and strength combined with acuteness and inquisitiveness; that practical, inventive turn of mind, quick to find expedients; that masterful grasp of things, lacking in the artistic but powerful to effect great ends; that restless, nervous energy: Citing the Census ofTurner is writing to announce the end of the frontier, and consequently, according to Turner, the end of the most crucial instrument in creating a sense of a unique American identity.

In his assault upon the Bank as an engine of aristocracy.

Frederick Jackson Turner

The frontier, they argued, shaped uniquely American institutions such as revivals, camp meetings, and itinerant preaching. Questions for Further Discussion 1. University of Oklahoma Press, They argue that such things as the civil war, slavery, immigration and the development of industrial capitalism.

State Historical Society of Wisconsin, The incorporation of these primary documents demonstrate how a seemingly unimportant and neglected body of sources can, in turn, be instrumental in understanding the lives, patterns, and conditions of the past Cronon, Turner offered his frontier thesis as both an analysis of the past and a warning about the future.

This is the frontier—the America—we have set ourselves to reclaim.Frederick Jackson Turners Frontier Thesis - PowerPoint PPT Presentation The presentation will start after a short (15 second) video ad from one of our sponsors. Limerick assaults the sacrosanct status of Frederick Jackson Turner's frontier process, but does so in a way that distinguishes her from many of the social history critiques of Turner from the s onwards (which she sees as having fragmentized the field and made it.

Frederick Jackson Turner, The Significance of the Frontier in American History () Born in Portage, Wisconsin in His father was a journalist by trade and a local historian by hobby. The Turner Thesis: A Historian's Controversy By J. A. BURKHART IN MEMBERS of the American Historical Association heard Frederick Jackson Turner read a paper entitled " The Signifi- cance of the Frontier in American History.".

Frederick Jackson Turner s Frontier Thesis

Frederick Jackson Turner was an American historian in the early 20th century. He promoted interdisciplinary and quantitative methods, often with a focus on the Midwest. He is best known for his essay "The Significance of the Frontier in American History", whose ideas formed the Frontier Thesis. The Turner Thesis: Concerning the Role of the Frontier in American History.

EP EP A collection of essays, by major frontier scholars, debating Turner's thesis and its impact on twentieth-century America.

A critique of fredrick jackson turners thesis about the ideals of the american west
Rated 5/5 based on 68 review